Part Two of the *bitter defeat* response to
Pitchfork's 200 Greatest Songs of the 1960sB. The Songs (cont'd)
#98 The Zombies - "Care of Cell 44"
Combining Beach Boys harmonies and Kinks-style English pastoralism, the opening track from The Zombies' finest album is a kitchen-sink masterpiece. And well done including the song at all (let alone in the top 100), as it never charted on either side of the Atlantic. Another fine album-track selection.
#92 Nick Drake - "River Man"
Here's a challenge, o music critic: let's see you write about Nick Drake without using the words "chilling," "mournful," or "haunting." Like those of Ian Curtis and Elliott Smith, Drake's legacy is eternally saddled with the circumstances of his own death, lending lazy critics and would-be eulogizers an arsenal of readymade miserabilisms for every occasion. Thus is the beauty and, dare we admit it, optimism at the heart of so much of Drake's music constantly elided. That's probably why "Time Has Told Me" didn't get the nod on this list instead: morbitity makes more compelling copy.
#91 The Who - "Substitute"
While not the first Who song to truly capture my imagination (that, strangely, was "Goin' Mobile" off of
Who's Next, which made me want to buy an RV and drive around for the rest of my life), "Substitute" brought with it my first realization that Pete Townshend was more than just the guy who wrote that opera about a traumatized pinball enthusiast. Before I ever knew what "mod" was, this song introduced the arch, adrenalized sneer of pissed-off lower-class kids with guitars. (This would later be labeled "punk," but rock-historical perspective was fairly remote from my 12-year-old existence.) Also, "I was born with a plastic spoon in my mouth"... Just fucking brilliant.
#85 Roy Orbison - "Crying"
Whence "In Dreams," P-fork?? If only for the Dean Stockwell lip-synch scene in
Blue Velvet, that gorgeous, triple-crescendo lament for lost love deserves inclusion here. The string arrangements in the song's final section are nothing short of sublime.
#76 BBC Radiophonic Workshop - "Doctor Who (Original Theme)"
Now I know what I said about the inclusion of jazz and avant-garde music in this list. And I'm aware that this test-tone electronic mishmash could be considered left-field. But I don't care. I love this pick. Itself owing a debt to Louis and Bebe Barron's music for
Forbidden Planet, the Doctor Who theme helped set the table for a whole slew of rock 'n' roll oddball moments. Including a little song called "Good Vibrations."
#65 The Mamas & the Papas - "California Dreamin'"
This song should probably have appeared higher on the list, and also brings us to the obvious question: Are these lists designed to drive people insane? Because with only 200 songs allowed, what happens to "Monday Monday" and "Creque Alley?"
#43 Vince Guaraldi Trio - "Linus & Lucy"
Oh by the sacred blood of Jesus Christ, give me a break. Get this motherfuckin' novelty pick off my motherfuckin' list.
#34 The Who - "The Kids Are Alright"
Complete bullshit this song being out of the top 10.
#32 Ennio Morricone - "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly (Main Theme)"
You know what I'm going to say. Iconic? Check. Brilliant? Check. A "song?" Hmmmm.
#31 Nico - "These Days"
Just a personal preference, but I think Nico's cover of Bob Dylan's "I'll Keep It With Mine" from the same album is far superior.
#26 The Beatles - "I Am the Walrus"
The larger issue of the Beatles songs on this list has already been broached, but this is clearly the most misguided selection. And it's especially egregious at #26. Not only are there several Beatles songs more deserving, compare this song to the next one on the list: "Paint It Black," at #25, isn't just a better song. It's in a completely different
league. Put "She Said, She Said" in this spot instead, and watch as it all suddenly comes together. A list is like a living, breathing organism; without its parts working together in flow and harmony, it gets list cancer and dies of shittiness.
#21 The Beach Boys - "Good Vibrations"
I'm just shocked that this is number 21. I was totally convinced the P-forkers would put this at number one.
#16 The Stooges - "I Wanna Be Your Dog"
Considered solely in terms of what has transpired in this song's wake, a compelling (if, in the end, unconvincing) argument could be made for placing this in the top slot. For once, the P-fork staff's predilection for verbal
sturm und drang can't overstate the song's significance. "Self-effacement," "numbed detachment," and good old fashioned nihilism run through this song like a collapsed vein. And let's not forget that this song rocks out with its cock(s) out. Just think about this: "I Wanna Be Your Dog" is the only song on the list that's still genuinely
dangerous over thirty years later. Consider this in light of #11, Led Zeppelin's "Dazed and Confused," which is lauded as "the numbest, blackest, taking-the-least-possible-amount-of-shit track any rock band ever recorded." Uh, yeah. Iggy smeared himself with peanut butter and rolled around in broken glass. Robert Plant formed a band called The Honeydrippers. Time to reconsider your idea of what's scary.
#10 Desmond Dekker & The Aces - "Israelites"
Great song, but it wins the Jessica Tandy Award for death-induced plaudits. Does this song hit number 10 if Desmond Dekker is still alive today? Or even if he died three years ago? No, it does not. They must have started the list before Syd Barrett died, or "See Emily Play" would have been #11.
#4 Bob Dylan - "Like a Rolling Stone"
All things considered, this would have been my overall number one. I'm not a big Dylan fanatic, but in addition to the song's sheer aesthetic appeal, one has to admit its pure iconic force. Something about this song -- some sonic combination of rage, wit, sprawling scope, and ultimate lack of resolution -- invokes the decade itself, both as a grand, romantic ideal and as a massive cultural letdown. "Like a Rolling Stone" induces a kind of frisson born of shame, fear, elation, and hope. In short, this song
is the sixties.
#2 The Jackson 5 - "I Want You Back"
Is a measured response to this choice even possible? To paraphrase Val Kilmer in
Real Genius, "Have you found humor?" Here's the thing: this really is a fantastic song. The arrangements are a stone groove... especially those high, proto-disco strings. The mellow backing vocals are a perfect foil for Jacko's endocrine-starved lead. Hell, if this had appeared at number 20, it would have come across as a genius pick; unexpected and unfuckwitable. At number 2? It's just wrong. Bad. A joke. It comes across as a gross tabulation error redolent of graft and dimpled chads. A golden entry in the "What The Fuck?" file.
#1 The Beach Boys - "God Only Knows"
Well it
is P-fork, so you knew it was going to involve Brian Wilson. Armed with this foregone conclusion, I would actually have preferred a lesser-known but more interesting
Pet Sounds track like "I'm Waiting for the Day." Hey, what are you gonna do? It's a beautiful song. No one was going to be completely happy with the top ten anyway, so you gotta follow your heart and keep in mind that most of your readers love Neutral Milk Hotel and Sufjan Stevens. This was the safest play. You big wussies.
C. Omissions
Finally, I give you a [roughly chronological] list of some songs that were tragically, unfairly omitted from Bitchfork's end-all-be-all:
The Ventures - "Walk Don't Run" (1960)
Probably the most popular rock 'n' roll instrumental of all time. Certainly one of the best.
Petula Clark - "Downtown" (1964)
A little cheesy? Well sure, but there's a reason Pet Clark's practically considered royalty in the UK. Pure sugary gold!!
The Animals - "House of the Rising Sun" (1964)
Probably the most glaring slight on P-fork's list. Drama, a kickass story, a simple ascending-chord riff... and I'm pretty sure it's about a whorehouse! "Sunny Afternoon" is the best song to hear in a bar. This is the best song to
sing in a bar.
Them - "Gloria" (1965)
The other candidate for "biggest omission." This is, after all, the most-covered song in rock 'n' roll history. There's a reason for that.
The Moody Blues - "Go Now" (1965)
I just like this song. It's genuinely tortured and sad. Really fun to belt out in the shower, and utterly shocking when considered against the band's later descent into proggy self-importance.
The Small Faces - "Itchycoo Park" (1967)
The year before they released the psych-rock classic
Ogden's Nut Gone Flake, the Small Faces brought forth the ultimate mod/hippie hybrid tune. "It's all too beautiful!"
Aretha Franklin - "Dr. Feelgood" (1967)
Aretha's sexiest song ever... by far. Basically it's about Aretha not needing anything else because her guy provides her with frequent orgasms. Queen of Soul gets
freakynaughty.Cream - "Sunshine of Your Love" (1967)/"Badge" (1969)
I couldn't decide. "Sunshine"'s deep, descending riff and ungodly (or Clapton-Is-Godly) solos are the stuff of supergroup legend, but the barroom piano and lyrical artistry of "Badge" (co-written by George Harrison) is possibly the band's pinnacle achievement.
Jimi Hendrix - "Crosstown Traffic" (1968)
I just love this goddamn song. And anyone who lives in New York City can attest to its metaphoric heft.
Dusty Springfield - "Windmills of Your Mind" (1969)
This version, from
Dusty in Memephis, may not appear in
The Thomas Crowne Affair, but it's certainly the definitive rendition. The song's imagery is vintage sixties, incorporating overwrought similies and the then-in-vogue language of psychotherapy. And Dusty builds from slow-and-smoky to almost hysterical. Far out cocktail-party music for hip moms and dads.